bBarzana/b Extra Virgin Olive Oil: Santa Ynez, CA. This is the priciest oil on my list at $16 a bottle, and it's also the lightest. I don't judge olive oil solely on color, but I'm skeptical of unsaturated hues of yellow. What this oil lacks in color it makes up for ... Informative post! On a vacation in Scottsdale last year, I found a wonderful California Olive Oil and have ordered it online a couple times. The Oils and Vinegars from DeVero Dry Creek bEstate/b are wonderful! ...